Train of Thought Review
Band | |
---|---|
Album | Train of Thought |
Type | Album (Studio full-length) |
Released | November 11, 2003 |
Genres | Progressive Metal |
Labels | Elektra Records |
Length | 1:09:22 |
Ranked | #1 for 2003 , #30 all-time |
Album rating : 92.8 / 100
Votes : 102 (6 reviews)
Votes : 102 (6 reviews)
July 25, 2015
Dream Theater's music has always been distasteful for me. I should admit that their instrumental parts are definitely above average; showing off their techniques on a very frequent basis. But here comes the awful part: James Labrie's cheesy, cringy, awkward, unnecessarily soft, icky vocals that don't go with the "heaviness" at all(the quotation marks because I don't think they do heavy music at all. They try their best do be as heavy as they can and fail so it's sort of funny). The vocals are what spoil everything.
Now, James' vocals were still suffering from the aftermath of what is known as the infamous taco poisoning; which, I think, actually served a great purpose for this album. Not only did James' vocals lose their wide range, but it also slightly changed the tone of his voice to a more raucous one. The change is sometimes unnoticably thin, though, so it still gets on my nerves immensely. [Vocals:0/100]
Dream Theater is a band praised for their allegedly amazing, skilled instrumental parts. I think I agree with that notion. However, a lot of times the band gets overboard with their skills to the point where it feels they're boasting how fast they can play whatever they're playing. Technique wise it may be good. However, most of the time it feels impertinent and redundant. They add nothing and fails to grasp the listener(me!)'s attention. In other words, it doesn't fit with the song. [Instruments: 70/100]
Now on to the overall track review. Mostly the tracks follow some sort of a similar track, and end up in a similar manner so I guessed it would be fine to write a review of your average DT song off Train of Thought.
The songs mostly open up with a nice heavy opening(with the exception of tracks 3 and 5). The riff feels actually quite well made. But then... What did I expect? James comes in with his vocals. I mean, it ain't Awake-level high, but the juxtaposition of the heavy downtuned guitar sounds with James' light, clean vocals is very, very strange and sometimes disgustingly awful to hear.
Here are the individual track points I gave:
As I Am : 75
This Dying Soul : 75
Endless Sacrifice : 40 (a super facetious attempt on writing a heavy ballad.)
Honour Thy Father : 50
Stream of Consciousness : 80(yay for instrumental tracks!)
In The Name of God : 60
The average adds up to 56.25, but since I'm feeling a bit generous today I'll round it up to 60 for a good measure.
Now, James' vocals were still suffering from the aftermath of what is known as the infamous taco poisoning; which, I think, actually served a great purpose for this album. Not only did James' vocals lose their wide range, but it also slightly changed the tone of his voice to a more raucous one. The change is sometimes unnoticably thin, though, so it still gets on my nerves immensely. [Vocals:0/100]
Dream Theater is a band praised for their allegedly amazing, skilled instrumental parts. I think I agree with that notion. However, a lot of times the band gets overboard with their skills to the point where it feels they're boasting how fast they can play whatever they're playing. Technique wise it may be good. However, most of the time it feels impertinent and redundant. They add nothing and fails to grasp the listener(me!)'s attention. In other words, it doesn't fit with the song. [Instruments: 70/100]
Now on to the overall track review. Mostly the tracks follow some sort of a similar track, and end up in a similar manner so I guessed it would be fine to write a review of your average DT song off Train of Thought.
The songs mostly open up with a nice heavy opening(with the exception of tracks 3 and 5). The riff feels actually quite well made. But then... What did I expect? James comes in with his vocals. I mean, it ain't Awake-level high, but the juxtaposition of the heavy downtuned guitar sounds with James' light, clean vocals is very, very strange and sometimes disgustingly awful to hear.
Here are the individual track points I gave:
As I Am : 75
This Dying Soul : 75
Endless Sacrifice : 40 (a super facetious attempt on writing a heavy ballad.)
Honour Thy Father : 50
Stream of Consciousness : 80(yay for instrumental tracks!)
In The Name of God : 60
The average adds up to 56.25, but since I'm feeling a bit generous today I'll round it up to 60 for a good measure.
1 like
Track listing (Songs)
title | rating | votes | video | ||
---|---|---|---|---|---|
1. | As I Am | 7:47 | 94.2 | 47 | Audio |
2. | This Dying Soul | 11:28 | 92.7 | 40 | Audio |
3. | Endless Sacrifice | 11:24 | 94.6 | 42 | Audio |
4. | Honor Thy Father | 10:14 | 93.5 | 42 | Audio |
5. | Vacant | 2:58 | 87 | 38 | Audio |
6. | Stream of Consciousness | 11:16 | 98.6 | 53 | Audio |
7. | In the Name of God | 14:15 | 97.4 | 45 | Audio |
Line-up (members)
- James LaBrie : Vocals
- John Petrucci : Guitars
- John Myung : Bass
- Mike Portnoy : Drums
- Jordan Rudess : Keyboards
10,029 reviews
cover art | Artist | Album review | Reviewer | Rating | Date | Likes | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
95 | 1 day ago | 4 | |||||
On Stage Review (1977) [Live] | 95 | 2 days ago | 0 | ||||
Of What's to Come Review (2008) | 85 | 3 days ago | 0 | ||||
85 | 3 days ago | 0 | |||||
Shotgun Justice Review (1990) | 100 | 6 days ago | 0 | ||||
Elements of Anger Review (1997) | 85 | 7 days ago | 0 | ||||
Rising Review (1976) | 100 | 7 days ago | 0 | ||||
Affect on Your Brain Review (1994) | 85 | 7 days ago | 0 | ||||
Metal Health Review (1983) | 90 | Apr 15, 2024 | 0 | ||||
Flamenco a Go-Go Review (2000) | 90 | Apr 14, 2024 | 0 | ||||
On the Prowl Review (1991) | 85 | Apr 12, 2024 | 0 | ||||
Death Is Little More Review (2024) | 95 | Apr 11, 2024 | 0 | ||||
Love at First Sting Review (1984) | 95 | Apr 8, 2024 | 1 | ||||
Greatest Hits Review (1981) [Compilation] | 90 | Apr 6, 2024 | 1 | ||||
Forbidden Review (1995) | 75 | Apr 6, 2024 | 0 | ||||
Sound of White Noise Review (1993) | 85 | Apr 6, 2024 | 0 | ||||
The Catalyst Review (2024) | 80 | Apr 5, 2024 | 0 | ||||
Japan Live '94 Review (1995) [Live] | 90 | Apr 5, 2024 | 1 | ||||
Superbloom Review (2023) | 95 | Apr 5, 2024 | 1 | ||||
30: Very Best of Deep Purple Review (1998) [Compilation] | 70 | Apr 4, 2024 | 0 |
Awake Review (1994)
구르는 돌 100/100
Aug 8, 2020 Likes : 13
범작보다도 더 많은 명작을 가진 Dream Theater지만 이들의 앨범들 중에서도 최고 명반을 뽑으라면 아마 Images And Words, Metropolis Pt. 2, 그리고 본작이 뽑힐 것이다. Images And Words야 90년대 프로그래시브 메탈의 효시로 여겨지면서, 현재까지도 많은 사람이 가장 선호하는 작품으로 알려져 있다. Met... Read More